Papa Johns Desserts Menu Prices and Nutritional Information

Craving something sweet after that perfect slice of pizza but not sure what to pick? You’re not alone. With so many tempting treats on the Papa Johns desserts list, it’s hard to know which one will really hit the spot. 

Whether you’re a fan of warm cookies, gooey cinnamon rolls, or a rich chocolate brownie, choosing the best dessert can feel like a tough call—especially when you also want to keep an eye on prices.

That’s where this guide comes in. We’ve broken down the full Papa Johns menu of sweet treats to help you decide what’s worth trying. If you’re looking to end your meal on a high note, check out detailed dessert descriptions, current prices, and choose the right one.

Papa Johns Desserts Menu

Papa Johns offers more than just great pizza—their desserts are just as tempting. From gooey chocolate treats to warm, cinnamon-filled bites, there’s something sweet for every craving. Each dessert is baked fresh and served warm, making it the perfect way to finish your meal.

Oreo Cookie Papa Bites​

Oreo Cookie Papa Bites are a sweet little treat packed with cookie flavor in every bite. These are made with Papa Johns’ original dough, stuffed with real Oreo cookie pieces, and baked until golden. They’re topped with icing and served with a creamy cheese dip on the side.

Oreo Cookie Papa Bites​
Price: $4.99/Cal: 100

Cinnamon Pull Aparts

Cinnamon Pull Aparts are warm, bite-sized rolls baked with sweet cinnamon and sugar. They’re topped with crumbly cinnamon bits and drizzled with rich cream cheese icing. Every piece is soft, gooey, and full of that classic cinnamon roll flavor.

Cinnamon Pull Aparts
Price: $7.99/Cal: 1960

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Papa Johns’ Chocolate Chip Cookie is a giant, warm, and chewy treat made for sharing. It’s baked fresh, sliced into 8 pieces, and packed with melty chocolate chips in every bite. It’s soft in the middle, slightly crisp on the edges, and always served warm. It’s just like a homemade cookie should be.

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Price: $7.99/Cal: 190

Double Chocolate Chip Brownie

The Double Chocolate Chip Brownie is a dream come true for chocolate fans. It’s soft, fudgy in the middle, slightly cakey on the outside, and loaded with rich chocolate chips. It is baked fresh and served warm in nine perfectly sized squares.

Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
Price: $7.99/Cal: 240

Papa Johns Pizza Desserts Nutritional Information

The nutritional information of desserts is given below:

Papa Johns Pizza Desserts Allergen Guide

The allergen guide of desserts is given below:

Dessert	Peanut	Tree Nut	Egg	Milk	Wheat	Soy	Fish	Shellfish	Sesame
Oreo Cookie Papa Bites				Yes	Yes	Yes
Cinnamon Pull Aparts	Maybe	Maybe	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Chocolate Chip Cookie	Maybe	Maybe	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie	Maybe	Maybe	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes

Best Dessert at Papa Johns

• Chocolate Chip Cookie is a clear favorite for many. It’s warm, chewy, and packed with melty chocolate chips—basically, a crowd-pleaser. 
• But if you’re into rich, fudgy flavors, the Double Chocolate Chip Brownie is a must-try. 

Every dessert at Papa Johns has its own fan base, so the best one really depends on your sweet tooth cravings.

FAQs